| Girls Big East All Conference | Boys Big East All Conference | |
| Name | Name | |
| First Team | First Team | |
| Madelynn Dephrey, Caribou | Chance Mercier, Ellsworth | |
| Grace Jaffray, Ellsworth | Pierce Walston, Orono | |
| Saige Evans, Old Town | Emmitt Byther, Old Town | |
| Claire Gaetani, John Bapst | Tristan Robbins, Caribou | |
| Abby Radel, Ellsworth | Ben Francis, Orono | |
| Second Team | Second Team | |
| Lexi Tozier, MDI | Jameson Weir, MDI | |
| Mollie Gray, MDI | Evan Donnell, Bucksport | |
| Taylor Loring, Old Town | Grayson Thibeault, Old Town | |
| Elizabeth Boles, Ellsworth | Caden Blackwood, Bucksport | |
| Makayla Emerson, Old Town | Kaymen Sargent, Caribou | |
| Isaiah Ervin, Houlton | ||
| Jack Buck, Presque Isle | ||
| Third Team | Third Team | |
| Georganna Curtis, Presque Isle | Clay Crosman, Washington Academy | |
| Amelia Callnan, Houlton | Will Francis, Orono | |
| Sophia Brophy, MDI | Donnie Marzoll, Washington Academy | |
| Madelyn Morrow, Caribou | Brody Hurd, Hermon | |
| Liv Adams, Caribou | Brendan Mahaney, Old Town | |
| Honorable Mention | Honorable Mention | |
| Chloe Kilton, Washington Academy | Bryce Edwards, Hermon | |
| Addison Clairmont, Presque Isle | ||
| Bella Bowden, Hermon | ||
| Player of the Year | Player of the Year | |
| Madelynn Deprey, Caribou | Chance Mericer, Ellsworth | |
| Coach of the Year | Coach of the Year | |
| Andy Pooler, Ellsworth | Garrett Libby, Old Town High School | |
| Sportsmanship Award | Sportsmanship Award | |
| John Bapst Memorial High School | Bucksport High School | |
| Conference Champions | Conference Champion | |
| Ellsworth High School | Ellsworth High School | |
| Conference Runner-up | Conference Runner-up | |
| Old Town High School | Old Town High School |
